By Basudev Acharya | |
Apart from issues related to seed monopoly and rural livelihood, there are serious biosafety concerns the world over. | |
Across the world, there is huge controversy around the introduction of genetically modified/engineered (GM/GE) crops. On one hand there are a few biotech crop developers and scientists recommending the use of GM technology as solution for food security and on other there are concerns about its impact on human health, environment and socioeconomy.
Added to that is the unpredictability and irreversibility of genetic engineering and the uncontrollability of GM crops once let out in the environment. One of the major concerns about GM crops is that they only serve the purpose of multinational seed giants. All GM technologies come along with Intellectual Property Rights and patent tags of multinational seed companies which would ensure their monopolies as has happened in the case of Bt cotton, the only GM crop commercially cultivated in India. While there were 619 varieties of Bt cotton approved for release until Aug 2009 in the country, 514 of them are owned by Monsanto, the US multinational seed giant, which also holds a global monopoly in the total seed sales of Bt cotton. One has already seen how Monsanto has armtwisted the state governments in India to increase the cotton seed prices this season. Bt Brinjal, the first GM food crop to have reached commercialisation stage in our country, also had a Cry 1Ac gene owned by Monsanto and licenced to Mahyco for developing Bt Brinjal. There is a threat of GM crops becoming the tool for control of the seed and thereby the agriculture sector by multinational seed corporations. Apart from issues related to seed monopoly and rural livelihood, there are serious biosafety concerns being debated world over. Different studies have consistently indicated the possible ill-effects of GMs on health and environment. There is a clear need for an independent report on various effects of GM crops, including long term studies and chronic toxicity studies. Biosafety concerns must be addressed before any open air release of GM crops including field trials. It is in this context that one should look at the growing debate on GM crops in India. The crisis in Indian agriculture needs no further statement, but to attribute it to just technology lag and promote technofixes, like GM crops, as the only solution to it is not only myopic but also criminal and this is precisely what the Indian government seems to be doing. The debate in India on GE crops started with Bt cotton, the only commercially approved GE crop in the country (March, 2002) and had become loud and visible around the approval of Bt Brinjal. During public consultations organised by the Union ministry of environment and forests last year on Bt Brinjal, there were concerns raised by farmers, civil society, and health and environment experts against GM crops and also against the existing regulatory system in the country, the government then rolled back the approval validating these concerns. Field trials Recommendations submitted by the Swaminathan Task Force on Agri-Biotechnology, whose report was accepted by the government in 2004, clearly stated that India should adopt such technologies as genetic engineering only where alternatives do not exist. It also categorically rejected technologies that would be detrimental to agriculture labour like the herbicide tolerant crops. To top it all the government is proposing a new regulatory system for GM crops called the Biotechnology Regulatory Authority of India (BRAI) which is supposed to be tabled in the monsoon session. From what one has seen of the media leaked versions of its drafts, BRAI is going to lower the bar for approvals of GM crops. The problems with the proposed bill starts with the grave conflict of interest where the regulator is proposed to be located in the ministry of science and technology which also has the mandate to promote GM crops in the country. The last version seen in the media paints the picture of a centralised technocratic body with pretty much no role for the elected representatives of the people of this country. It did not have longterm biosafety assessments and also maintains the current system of letting the GM crop developer do the biosafety assessment. It also proposed to circumvent the Right to Information Act, 2005, and went even to the extent of proposing imprisonment and fines for those opposing GM crops without scientific evidence. Thus the BRAI that government plans to put in place, at its onset looks like a non transparent, unquestionable authority. Given that the existing regulatory system is defunct, what needs to be immediately done is stopping the release of any GM crop in to our environment be it for commercialisation or for research. We should not fail to ask fundamental questions like whether there is a need for this technology and whether safer and sustainable alternatives exist for a proposed product. This is what the existing and proposed regulatory systems for GM crops fail to do in India and the fact is that for any GM crop that is being developed in any part of the word right now, there exists ecological alternatives which are economically and socially sustainable. (The writer is the chairman of parliament’s standing committee on agriculture) |
Palagummi Sainath | Indian Journalist
Secure Donations to Act Naturally. Thank you for your kind support.
UK Anti-GMO Action
- Alliance for Natural Health Europe
- Caerhys Organic Community Agriculture (COCA)
- Community Food Growers Network
- GM Free Cymru
- GM Free Ireland
- GM Free Scotland (Blog)
- GMO Compass
- GMO Free News from UK
- Institute for Science and Technology (UK)
- Local Organizing Toolkit
- Munlochy GM Vigil
- Natural Law Party of the UK
- OrganicLea
- Pesticide Action Network UK
- Say No to GMO
- Slow Food Movement
- Soil Association
India | Land Rights, GMO & Farming Legislation
- Farm Land Grab
- Forest Rights Act, India
- Land Aquisition Resettlement and Rehabilitation Act 1894
- Ministry of Tribal Affairs (Gov. Site)
- PESA Act 1996
- Plant Varieties and Farmers Rights Acts 2001
- Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers Rights (Govt Site)
- Redevelopment and Resettlement Bill 2007
- Seed Bill of 2004
- Special Economic Zones Act Legal Summery
- The Indian Constitution
- The Indian Seed Patent Act, Sowing the Seeds of Dictatorship
- THE SPECIAL ECONOMIC ZONES ACT, or SEZ, 2005
Anti-GMO Organic Movements
- Agrarian Crisis Info India
- Amrita Bhoomi
- Bija Vidyapeeth Navdanya
- Buddha Community Farm
- Deccan Development Society
- Farm Land Grab
- Food for Life Vrindavan
- Friends of Earth International
- Green Conserve
- India GM Info
- IndiaGMInfo
- Kheti Virasat Mission
- La Via Campasina
- Maharashatra Organic Farming Federation
- Morarkaorganic Rajastan
- Mr. Save system of Organic Farming
- Non GMO Project
- Organic Farmers Association of India
- Promoting Economic Justice for Small Scale Farming
- Sharad Joshi Farmers Liberal Movement Page
- SOS Organics
- Timbaktu Collective
- Urban Leaves India
- Zero Budget Natural Farming
Blogroll
Educate & Activate Videos
Farmer Suicides
Dalit and Adivasi Struggle
Khet Virasat Mission
- Sustainable Productivity and Soil Fertility through Enhanced Soil Biology By Dr Om Rupela June 9, 2016Sustainable Productivity and Soil Fertility through Enhanced Soil BiologyOm RupelaFormer Scientist, International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT), Patancheru, 502324, Andhra Pradesh, IndiaE-mail: oprupela@gmail.com, Phone: 9490621798India’s growing population needs a proportional increase in food production. Much of the land i […]noreply@blogger.com (Kheti Virasat Mission - The ecological movement for Punjab)
- Story of Stakeholder’s Workshop on GM Crops May 30, 2015Story of Stakeholder’s Workshop on GM Crops MARKETING OF GM CROPS IN THE NAME OF DISCUSSING SOCIO-ECONOMIC CONSIDERATIONS?AGRICULTURE RESEARCH ESTABLISHMENTS JOIN HANDS WITH GM INDUSTRYBy Ajay Tripathi and Kartik Kwatra The “Stakeholder’s workshop on Socio-economic considerations of GM crops” jointly organized by Department of Extension educ […]noreply@blogger.com (Kheti Virasat Mission - The ecological movement for Punjab)
- Bayer CEO started Medical Apartheid: Denies its Cancer medicine to Indians February 1, 2014Bayer CEO started Medical Apartheid: Denies its Cancer medicine to IndiansMNCs are only for ruthless profits regardless of any ethic, morality and human value. The recent statement made by Mr. Marijn Dekkers, CEO of agro-chemical and pharmaceutical giant Bayer precisely told that these Corporations are meant for extracting money and extortion at any cost. […]noreply@blogger.com (Kheti Virasat Mission - The ecological movement for Punjab)
- How to Grow Wheat in Organic / Natural / Sustainable Agriculture November 23, 2013Scoping Comparable Yields, Rice-Wheat Cropping System, With and Without Agro-Chemicals, Punjab, IndiaAn Experiment ProtocolThis experiment is based on the discussion of farmers associated with Kheti Virasat Mission and practicing Organic / Natural Farming in Punjab under the Chairmanship of eminent Agriculture Scientist Dr O P Rupela. It is focused on yield […]noreply@blogger.com (Kheti Virasat Mission - The ecological movement for Punjab)
- How to grow Wheat in Organic , Natural and Sustainable Farming November 23, 2013Scoping Comparable Yields, Rice-Wheat Cropping System, With and Without Agro-Chemicals, Punjab, IndiaAn Experiment ProtocolThis experiment is based on the discussion of farmers associated with Kheti Virasat Mission and practicing Organic / Natural Farming in Punjab under the Chairmanship of eminent Agriculture Scientist Dr O P Rupela. It is focused on yield […]noreply@blogger.com (Kheti Virasat Mission - The ecological movement for Punjab)
- An Experiment Protocol for Organic and Naturally Grown Wheat in Punjab November 23, 2013Scoping Comparable Yields, Rice-Wheat Cropping System, With and Without Agro-Chemicals, Punjab, IndiaAn Experiment ProtocolThis experiment is based on the discussion of farmers associated with Kheti Virasat Mission and practicing Organic / Natural Farming in Punjab under the Chairmanship of eminent Agriculture Scientist Dr O P Rupela. It is focused on yield […]noreply@blogger.com (Kheti Virasat Mission - The ecological movement for Punjab)
- An Experiment Protocol for Organic and Naturally Grown Wheat in Punjab November 23, 2013Scoping Comparable Yields, Rice-Wheat Cropping System, With and Without Agro-Chemicals, Punjab, IndiaAn Experiment ProtocolThis experiment is based on the discussion of farmers associated with Kheti Virasat Mission and practicing Organic / Natural Farming in Punjab under the Chairmanship of eminent Agriculture Scientist Dr O P Rupela. It is focused on yield […]noreply@blogger.com (Kheti Virasat Mission - The ecological movement for Punjab)
- An Experiment Protocol for Organic and Naturally Grown Wheat in Punjab November 23, 2013Scoping Comparable Yields, Rice-Wheat Cropping System, With and Without Agro-Chemicals, Punjab, IndiaAn Experiment ProtocolThis experiment is based on the discussion of farmers associated with Kheti Virasat Mission and practicing Organic / Natural Farming in Punjab under the Chairmanship of eminent Agriculture Scientist Dr O P Rupela. It is focused on yield […]noreply@blogger.com (Kheti Virasat Mission - The ecological movement for Punjab)
- An Experiment Protocol for Organic and Naturally Grown Wheat in Punjab November 23, 2013Scoping Comparable Yields, Rice-Wheat Cropping System, With and Without Agro-Chemicals, Punjab, IndiaAn Experiment ProtocolThis experiment is based on the discussion of farmers associated with Kheti Virasat Mission and practicing Organic / Natural Farming in Punjab under the Chairmanship of eminent Agriculture Scientist Dr O P Rupela. It is focused on yield […]noreply@blogger.com (Kheti Virasat Mission - The ecological movement for Punjab)
- An Experiment Protocol for Organic and Naturally Grown Wheat in Punjab November 23, 2013Scoping Comparable Yields, Rice-Wheat Cropping System, With and Without Agro-Chemicals, Punjab, IndiaAn Experiment ProtocolThis experiment is based on the discussion of farmers associated with Kheti Virasat Mission and practicing Organic / Natural Farming in Punjab under the Chairmanship of eminent Agriculture Scientist Dr O P Rupela. It is focused on yield […]noreply@blogger.com (Kheti Virasat Mission - The ecological movement for Punjab)
- Sustainable Productivity and Soil Fertility through Enhanced Soil Biology By Dr Om Rupela June 9, 2016
Advertisements